In this fast-growing and digitally transforming world of product development, the prototyping process is of high importance. The selection of the proper procedures for the development of the prototypes can considerably affect design accuracy as well as cost and time to market. Nowadays, there are two of the most commonly used technologies, CNC machining vs 3D printing for prototyping. But when it comes to accuracy, speed, and scalability is which technique is better?

According to a Sculpteo study, 48% of businesses use 3D printing for rapid prototyping, and 37% use the CNC technique for functional components.

In this detailed comparison of CNC machining vs 3D Printing for Prototyping applications, we will compare the advantages and disadvantages of each, discuss the main use cases, as well as provide some real world considerations in order to enable you to make an informed decision on what is best for your product development process.

CNC 가공이란 무엇인가요? 

Computer numeric control CNC 가공 is a subtractive process that involves the removal of material by subtractive processes using the cutters programmed through computers from the solid block. CNC machines are famous for high precision part that they produce and are used in large scale in aerospace, automotive and medical industries.

Common CNC materials include:

• Aluminium
• Steel
• 황동
• ABS and other engineering plastics

What is 3D Printing?

3D 프린팅 or additive manufacturing produces things digitally from layer to layer. Such a process is perfect for developing complex geometries and individual parts with the least amount of material waste.

Common 3D printing materials:

• PLA, ABS
• 나일론
• Resin
• Metal powders (in industrial printers)

CNC Machining vs 3D Printing for Prototyping: Key Differences

Let us see the main differences that count the most when comparing CNC machining vs 3d printing for prototyping industry techniques.

Both technologies have their strengths, but the better choice depends on your prototype’s goal, functionality, speed, or appearance.

When to use CNC machining for prototypes?

CNC machining is the perfect solution if you do:

• Functional prototypes resembling those in final production materials
• Tolerance classes and dimensional accuracy.
• Superior mechanical strength
• Fast turnaround on metal prototypes
• High-quality surface finishes

그리고 CNC machine market worldwide is projected to reach $117.65 billion by 2027, advancing at a CAGR of 5.5% (Source: Fortune Business Insights).

Industry Example

CNC machining would be an advantage for a medical device firm requiring stainless steel prototypes for use in regulatory testing because of its strength and precision.

Applicability of 3D printing for prototyping purposes.

• If your project requires it, choose 3D printing.
• Cost-effective rapid prototyping.
• Design flexibility with complex shapes
• Faster iteration cycles
• Reduced material waste
• Conceptual models or visual mockups

그리고 global 3D printing market is set to grow at a CAGR of 20.8% to reach $76.17 billion in 2030 (Source: Grand View Research).

Field Example

A start-up experimenting with multiple ergonomic forms of a wearable gadget can easily alter them, with millions of variations if 3D printed from FDM or SLA (Fusion Deposition Modeling and Stereolithography).

결론

The question is still there that CNC machining vs 3D printing for the prototyping which is better? We can only say that It all depends on your goals. If you are after precision, strength and real world functionality CNC machining is your go to solution. If you are after speed, flexibility, and cost- effectiveness, 3D printing is the best option.

In most instances uniting the technologies using a staged prototyping process provides the best results. Early 3D printed models enable you to validate ideas quickly, and CNC milled prototypes give you the functionality required to test and validate production.

Select the appropriate tool for the job and your prototype will do more than look good; it’ll work.

자주 묻는 질문

Which is more accurate: CNC machining or 3D printing?

CNC machining is typically more accurate, providing tighter tolerances (±0.001”) than most 3D print methods.

Is CNC machining more costly than 3D printing?

Yes, especially for small batches. CNC’s costs per setup and tooling are higher compared to 3D printing, which is cheaper for creating early prototypes.

Are 3D printed parts applicable to functional testing?

Yes, but with limitations. FDM or resin prints fail to resist stress in the same way as a CNC-machined metal part.

Which method is preferable, faster for prototyping?

It depends; 3D printing is faster on complex designs, while CNC is quicker on simple parts out of solid blocks.

Can both technologies be combined?

Absolutely. Most companies use 3D printing for mockups and CNC machining for final functional prototypes.